The latest reports from Italıan sources has struck the football world like a bombshell: Manchester United want to bring Scott McTominay back, just a short time after parting ways in the summer of 2024.
However, this potential Scott McTominay transfer is no longer a simple story of a homecoming; the player they would face across the negotiating table is no longer the “squad rotation” option once deemed expendable in the Premier League.
Since his move to Italy, the Scotsman has transformed into a true phenomenon, winning the Scudetto with Napoli and establishing himself as one of Europe’s most in-form midfielders.
While Manchester United’s management prepares to knock on their former son’s door to address their lack of midfield dynamism, reports from the Napoli camp suggest that this Scott McTominay Transfer will be anything but cheap.
For the Red Devils, this pursuit represents both an admission of a massive tactical error and a daunting financial challenge. Even if the fans are excited, finalising a Scott McTominay transfer under these new circumstances will require a record-breaking effort.
Scott McTominay Transfer: Manchester Days
Scott McTominay’s career at Manchester United was always built on sacrifice and a deep sense of belonging.
As a graduate of the club’s academy, he was the “emergency saviour” for every manager from Jose Mourinho to Erik ten Hag. Yet, he rarely received the credit he truly deserved.
To many United fans, he was a polarising figure – at times criticised for his technical limitations, at others cheered for his sheer grit and passion. However, by the summer of 2024, citing financial sustainability rules and squad restructuring, he was sold to Napoli for a fee of 25 million pounds – a figure that looks laughable in today’s market.
As the United midfield crumbled without his physical presence and knack for scoring crucial goals, McTominay’s departure has become one of the most questioned transfer decisions in the club’s recent history.
YOU MAY ALSO LIKE: Eberechi Eze: Mikel Arteta Explains Decisions in Arsenal vs Brentford 1-1 Draw as Martin Odegaard Injury Sparks Crisis
Scott McTominay Transfer: Napoli’s Golden Boy
From the moment he set foot in Italy, McTominay was essentially reborn within Antonio Conte’s tactical system, more than living up to his “McTerminator” nickname.
Playing a pivotal role in Napoli’s 2024/25 Serie A title (Scudetto) triumph, the Scottish star was voted the league’s MVP, not just for his defensive resilience but for his late runs into the box and clinical finishing.
Starting this season in explosive form, McTominay recently added the Italian Super Cup to his trophy cabinet, proving his success was no fluke. Now a beloved icon for the Napoli faithful, the 29-year-old’s market value has skyrocketed to at least three times what United sold him for – nearly 80 million euros.
Blending the tactical discipline of Italian football with his own raw physical power, Scott is now regarded as one of Europe’s elite box-to-box midfielders.
Scott McTominay Transfer: Can United Reclaim Their Lost Soul?
At this stage, Manchester United’s desire to re-sign Scott McTominay serves as a belated confession of a strategic blunder.
However, the terms of this deal will not be dictated by United, but by Napoli’s notoriously tough Chairman, Aurelio De Laurentiis. For a player who has reached the pinnacle in Italy as a league and cup champion, the English giants will have to present an “astronomical” offer.
Manchester United may now have to pay a heavy price for failing to value their own homegrown talent.
In short, McTominay is no longer just a “role player”; he is a leader who keeps his team in the championship race.
If United can pull off this move, they will regain more than just a player – they will reclaim a piece of their lost character. But Napoli have no intention of letting go of their crown jewel easily.
Main Photo
Credit: IMAGO / Buzzi
Recording Date: 07.02.2026
Mctominay’s performance in Napoli is obvious, but I do not know if he can continue this performance in United, especially considering his relationship with the fans.